This market just makes you want to scream, doesn’t it? Now you know why I stay out of sick markets and sold my MHS days ago. Here is a stock that broke to a new all-time high at the end of March and held up for a few weeks. It seemed like a good “defensive” stock, being in the management of prescription drug programs. So what happened today? It announces quarterly earnings today up 27% but apparently did not boost its profit outlook for the rest of the year. So what does it do? It declines today 9.12%! This is the type of action one gets in a market that is in a downtrend with few stocks successfully holding new high ground.
WishingWealth 10 day successful new high index: 4/25 20; 4/22 19; 4/21 28; 4/20 12
Range since March, 2005: 8-106 (This index counts the number of stocks, of 4,000, that hit a 52 week high 10 days ago and closed today greater than they did 10 days ago.) With only 20/4000 stocks hitting new highs and continuing to rise, it would seem to me that this is not the time to buy stocks trading at new highs. I will wait for a stronger market. I have a similar index that counts new lows that continue to decline–it is 56 today. New lows are a better bet than new highs these days.
Housing stocks (and MHS) popped today. Housing’s downtrend appears to me to still be intact. The market’s volume on the rise seems unspectacular. As I have noted before, I would need to see much more strength before my indicators would signal a turn. Let’s see what happens after earning are all out. Remember, all of these earnings represent the past and the market always is looking forward.
I received the following explanation about the short term interest rate index that I highlighted yesterday: IRX-X data come from the CBOE symbol IRX-E. You can get more information on the IRX-X by clicking the link:
As best I can tell, this index tracks the yield of the 13 week treasury bills. Maybe we should be trading these options–as we saw yesterday, this index sure does trend. If any readers know more about these options, please email me so I can pass it on.
“Want to know how to make a small fortune in the stock market?
Start with a large fortune!”
I thought you would probably want me to back off of the strategy discussion (see yesterday’s post) and to return to my take on the market. A number of people have written to me about going short. This interest, together with the skepticism about the market’s rally in the media cause me to pause, just a little. However, I do not reverse direction until my market indicators start to change. So, I wait, mainly in cash and put options in my IRA. (I did sell my one small long position, MHS–I got tired of holding anything at odds with the general market trend.) The attached chart (click on it to enlarge) shows the consistent rising trend in short term interest rates that started in May, 2004. (I have asked the TC2005 support staff at Worden.com to tell me the basis for this index, and will report back on their answer.) The Fed’s persistent pressure on rates is one of the obstacles to a rising market. Historically, in its fear of inflation, the Fed typically misjudges how much to put on the brakes and eventually brings the market and the economy to a screeching halt. (In spite of this track record, traders tend to delude themselves into thinking that this time will be different and we will get a “soft landing.”) This short term interest rate index has been hugging its rising 10 week moving average for months, and just bounced off of the average to a new high, after a few weeks of a plateau. This renewed rise is not a good omen. A consistent reversal in this index will probably foreshadow a subsequent bottom in the market–but not immediately. So, we will keep an eye on this index.
IBD’s Monday edition published a put/call ratio of .86. This means that 86 puts were traded for every 100 calls. (Puts are options that gain when the underlying security falls; calls gain as a security rises. In other words, puts are bets by option traders that a security will fall, calls are bets on a rise. Did I imply that people are gambling?) This ratio is a contrarian indicator, which means that it typically predicts the opposite type of market movement than would be expected from the trades. If an extremely high number of option traders are bearish (buying more puts than calls) then the market often tends to rise, at least short term. People are most scared at bottoms and overly optimistic at tops. Most of the time, traders are more bullish than bearish and the p/c ratio is below .80. When it stays above .80 for a while and gets above 1.0, the market usually is in store for a bounce. The current ratio is not at an extreme. However, if it breaks 1.0 this week it may signal short term strength in the market. If the P/C ratio starts to trend lower in this depressing environment, say below .60, watch out below!
I am short some housing stocks. It is rare that I find so many companies in an industry with the charts looking so sick. Here are a few, in no special order: RYL,OHB,LR,LEN,MDC,MHO,DHOM,WCI,SPF,DHI. I did not run out of ugly symbols, but you get the picture. Even lofty NVR appears to have broken its uptrend on a number of large volume declines. Is it too late to sell these? Who knows, but the current trend is obvious to me. Could insiders possibly be showing us something about the future of housing? Watch behavior, not words.
I hope you have a good trading day tomorrow. The trend is your friend.
WishingWealth 10 day successful new high index: 4/22 19; 4/21 28; 4/20 12 (for definition, see Madness post)
“it is utterly useless for us on the outside, who buy and sell comparatively small blocks of stock, to conjecture about what “they” are doing. We cannot know what the insiders intend to do, but we can see their orders on the tape when they execute them. That is why my plea is for everyone of us to have no mere opinions of his own, but to allow the actions of the market to tell him what is passing.”
(Humphrey B. Neill, Tape Reading & Market Tactics, 1931, New York: B.C. Forbes Publishing Company; 14th printing, 2003, Vermont: Fraser Publishing Company)
When Nicolas Darvas was interviewed by Time Magazine in the early 60’s and it came out that he made almost 2 million dollars in the market in 18 months (while he was dancing around the world!), he noted that he read and reread Neill’s book (along with Gerald Loeb’s). Neill’s book has been reprinted many times and I happened to find it on the shelf of my local Barnes and Noble store. Neill dedicates his book, “to my losses, with a deep appreciation for the experience and knowledge which each loss has brought me.”
"Just when you think you have the key to the market, someone changes the locks."
So Dow 10,000 held. This number means so much to people that had it simply given way quickly, we probably would have been hit with a climactic sell-off that would have ended the decline. But we did not. The Dow had fallen from 10,507.97 to 10012.36 in only 6 days. Does a 200 point rally nullify a 500 point decline? Is this a bottom?
To me, little has changed. The market is still in a down trend. The Dow would have to close 300 points higher for me to start to consider the bull case. Yes, even in spite of Yahoo and Google, the exceptions that prove the rule. I did not stop out of MHS, my lone holding, today. The new high index I described yesterday climbed from 12 to 28, still a paltry number of stocks that traded at new highs 10 days ago and closed higher today than 10 days ago. After earnings season is over there will likely be a lull during which traders will focus again on inflation, recession, deficits and the Fed.
I have been using the term bear market–and this habit is dangerous. It is much safer to say that the market is in a down trend. Once I choose to use terms like bull or bear market it influences my judgment and it leads to predictions. For example, if one labels the market as a bear it implies that it should last a certain amount of time that bear markets typically last and end in a certain way. One tends to marry a scenario. I may hang onto this scenario in order to be right (ego again). Ever get so attached to a story that you can’t observe what is actually happening? It happens all of the time in the market. People say things like, we should have a consolidation period followed by a rise or fall,or the market needs to rest. The talking heads do this every day when they pontificate about what should unfold. (So did I, when I said above that the market will enter a lull post-earnings.)
But I try not to predict. I analyze the current market trend. Are we rising, declining or stable or is it impossible to discern. Right now, I believe the trend is still down. I never know how long the trend will last. When my rules and indicators suggest a turn, I can turn on a dime and slowly wade back into the market on the long side. There is plenty of time to catch the real rockets after they have left the launch pad. More on strategy this weekend.
Please continue to send me your questions and comments. I value your support.
I exited the market in the fall of 2000. I became incensed as the NASDAQ was falling over the next 2 years and the media pundits were telling us to buy and hold and to go after the bargains. Day after day they were wrong and yet people continued to listen to them. I remember one adviser who recommended Exodus Communications when it was down to 65 from the 80’s, and continued praising its virtues all the way down until the company was finally de-listed. And yet this person had the nerve to come back each week and opine on the market and to offer his picks. The tragedy was that many persons lost their savings and their plans for early retirement.
So has anything changed since then? Today, in spite of the strong downtrend in the general market, the media gurus of the day are looking for safe stocks to buy–the few defensive stocks that will hold up. Maybe they would lose their audience if they came out and told people to sell their stocks and stay in cash, never mind sell short. They just keep telling us to look for the safe stocks–the needle in the haystack. But the bear devours everything before it is through. Why do they insist on fighting the trend? I certainly will not–the decline continues. Over the years I have noticed that the market seers do not declare a bull or bear market until about 6 months after it has begun. The NASDAQ topped out in January and the DOW in March. When will we hear the first declaration of a bear market from the talking heads? Stop this Madness.
My short positions made money today. The housing stocks continue to crack. This is probably just the beginning. My lone long, MHS, did not hold up well today. I may be stopped out tomorrow. Over and over, I learn that to fight the trend is folly. Don’t buy stocks now–any stocks. I am mainly short and in cash. Nothing feels better than to be in synch with the trend.
My primary trading strategy is to buy growth stocks trading at or near new highs. I rode Yahoo up 100 points on two occasions and sold out above 400. I buy high and sell higher. But a hard lesson to learn is that the strategy that does beautifully in a bull market fails miserably in a bear market. (Check out the book by Nicolas Darvas, How I made………, for a nice description of this phenomenon.) A good indication that things are souring is when the types of trades I have been profiting from suddenly produce a string of losses.
There are several other indicators that tell me when my growth stock strategy is unlikely to work. First of all, if there are not at least 100 stocks on the NYSE or NASDAQ that are making new 52 week highs, the market is not strong enough. These days, new lows are more common than new highs–a very bad sign. Second, IBD (Investor’s Business Daily) publishes a chart each day of the IBD mutual fund index. This index tracks the performance of 23 growth mutual funds. I have found that if this index is below its 50 day moving average, then I cannot make money trading growth stocks. In other words, if the pros running these funds cannot make money I will not. These managers are the ones who drive these growth stocks higher with their huge resources. Currently, the IBD index is below its 50 day average and even in jeopardy of penetrating its 200 day average. (The 50 day moving average is simply the average of all closing prices during the past 50 days. It changes or moves each day as a new close is added and the oldest close is dropped.) As of Wednesday, the index was down 6.15% for the year. In this climate do we really want to risk our money buying growth stocks?
I have also used TC2005 (go to Worden.com to learn about this impressive charting program) to compute a new index of the strength of stocks that are hitting new highs. I scan each of the 4,000 stocks in my stock universe (active stocks trading above $5) and count the number of stocks that hit a new 52 week high 10 days ago that have closed today higher than they closed 10 days ago when they hit the new high. If stocks that hit new highs cannot continue rising, the future for new highs is bleak. When I first computed this index in March, I found that over 100 stocks met these criteria. Today, there were only 12 stocks out of 4,000 that hit a new high 10 days ago and closed higher today than 10 days ago. With odds of 12/4000, why would anyone seek to buy stocks that are hitting new highs with the expectation of seeing them climb higher? I will continue to compute this index and report on any significant changes.
Before I close, let me share with you my thoughts about another ploy for scaring people from getting out of the market. Ever read those analyses that say that if you were out of the market during the "X" days of biggest gains, you would have missed most of the bull market move. I think most people accept this logic at face value. But I think it is absurd. For example, say the market climbs 100 points in one day and you were out of the market. The market could decline and retrace much of that move on the subsequent days or weeks, when you could have bought in. You did not necessarily lose the full 100 points. Furthermore, given that we cannot predict the market’s daily moves, who in the world would be so unlucky so as to miss all or most of the days of big moves? I stay out of the market during times like these or go short. There is always time to catch a genuine bull move. Am I missing something here?
Send me your comments and questions.
The response to my first two posts has been unexpected and welcome. Thanks to a link from a most valuable investing blog (www.thekirkreport.com), I received over 1400 hits Tuesday. Some emails/comments asked for more trading details. That will come as I become accustomed to this medium.
I have found that the daily news breaks cause only minor effects on the market– temporary deviations from the market’s trend. So I do not pay much attention to tonight’s earnings announcements from INTC and YHOO. Yes, we may get more of a bounce in the techs, but still within a solid downtrend. A 56 point rise after a 400+ point drop in the Dow is quite puny and reflects a sick market. The DOW could rise another 300 points and still not break the downtrend. The NASDAQ composite would have to rise to 2,000 before I would begin to question the bear trend.
After the market confirms a real turn, there is plenty of time to get on board with buys. We are interested in a trend that lasts months not days. I don’t let the pundits scare me into the market prematurely–there is plenty of time to ride a real bull. The successful traders say there is a time to be out of the market–why trade long before the market meets my conditions for maximum success. Real bottoms typically take time to form with at least one re-test of the lows.
So, right now I am sitting with puts in stocks in housing, auto-related, employment related and mortgage related industries. My puts are good through June or beyond, so I can wait for the decline to resume. (I buy deep in the money puts so there is little time premium to pay, but more risk.)
XMSR is looking sick to me—maybe the decline in car sales will hurt their subscription growth. I originally bought XMSR when it was $2/share and traded it several times. The company still has no earnings. (I don’t have a position in it now.)
Because I swim with the tide, I should own no stocks now. However, I could not resist nibbling on a drug store stock (MHS) that has been hitting new highs. I think new medicare prescription benefits will take effect early next year. Perhaps MHS and LDG are benefiting from this. I set a close stop one point below my purchase price–I know the odds against a long profitable rise are against me. In a weak market traders take profits quickly, thus truncating the rise.
I have no reluctance to take quick small losses. I make a purchase and set a sell stop and forget it–take the emotion out of it. Every loss brings me to the next gain. It took me 30 years to get to this point. Trading is about making money not being right. A big ego gets in the way of successful trading. More on all of this later.
Thanks for listening.